I agree with Florian - charisma is much more important than typical "good looks." There are plenty of visually attractive people who are completely uninteresting to watch or look at, and there are plenty of strange-looking or average-looking people who are very compelling.
As an example, my favorite American actor is probably Christopher Walken. He's pretty much the opposite of any typical idea of a "handsome" man, but he's extremely interesting, and he's also an excellent performer, which is what I want to see when I watch a film. Pretty people who can't act make terrible movies.
I do think that the American film industry in particular has been getting worse and worse about hiring "pretty" people instead of talented people. If you watch shows or movies from thirty or forty years ago, and especially movies from 50+ years ago, you'll see a lot more average-looking or even very strange-looking guys.
Unfortunately, the movie industry has always seemed to prefer pretty women over women with talent, and the beauty standards are still higher for women, even though they're getting higher for men, too. I think the UK is doing much better lately about casting actors and actresses who are more average looking, older, and more culturally diverse. I think audiences actually enjoy this. Of course, when we watch a movie or show, we do want to see something we enjoy. But I hope Hollywood will figure out that audiences enjoy a lot of things besides stereotypical beauty.