Search from various English teachers...
India flagSom (সোম)
Is there an advantage in being a native speaker for teaching a language?
By definition, a native speaker has a better grasp of idiom and dialect. They also have a "feel" for the language, that is, if it "sounds right" or "is a bit off". If they are well educated, this feel extends to good style. On the other hand, most tend to forget the rigorous rules of grammar even if they had studied it in school. To that extent, a native speaker is the best choice to learn the living language as it is really spoken and gain fluency.

A teacher is different. They study the target language rigorously for many more years than a normal person would. To that extent one expects them to know the formal grammar, vocabulary and style much better than others. This should also apply to those who teach a language that's not their mother tongue, provided they have otherwise reached the proficiency level normally attributed to native speakers. A regular teacher would be a good choice for those who wish to learn a language analytically rather than by some form of immersion.

Any thoughts on this?

Footnote: While I had to select a language under "this discussion is for learning" drop down, the proposition is not specific to English or any other language. I had to choose something because the submit button remains disabled otherwise.

Comments · 17

3
A lot of people of course want to learn from a native, the conversational part is something I learned from natives as well. I do agree with you that for people who learned the language from scratch and in a rigorous manner, there is a huge advantage for non-natives. Like in my case, I am a non-native speaker of English but students come to me because they can see that my ability exceeds their expectations. Teaching is not just about the ability to speak but it is so much more than that.I for one studied English and I know the process extremely well. I know how to teach IELTS, TOEFL to a fellow non-native speaker because I went through the process of reviewing and taking the test. There is a great number of native speakers who cannot teach the IELTS even if they are native. They have no idea even of what the examination is about.You can be a native speaker but it does not mean you can teach. When people message me if I can teach Filipino, I declined even if they double my rate. Why? It is for a simple fact that even if my native language is Filipino, it does not mean that I can teach it as proficiently and effectively as I teach the English language. There is a greater expectation for native teachers in terms of teaching their own language, some live up to it and some fall short.
2
Yes I think they do.

If you saying "what makes a better teacher, (a) a native speaker without any training, or (b) a highly trained non-native speaker?" then probably (b).

However, if both are highly trained, then this difference disappears, and it depends more on the individual skills of the teachers.

Probably, the native speaker will find the training quicker and easier, because of the background they have. It is also less work for them to get a "feel" for the language (because they were already doing this all their life). They may also be more aware of regional accents and dialects, which are harder for non-native speakers to get familiar with.

So, in the end, the native speaker may not be the better teacher - they just have a head start in becoming a good teacher.
1
D'accord. I do take Spanish lessons on iTalki from native speakers, but my "lessons" are purely conversation practice. For that, native speakers are the best.
1
@Som Yes it is the same and also you can use the term "Filipino" as a term to call the people and the language. Tagalog is more of a dialect . The beauty of teaching is it is a skill. It does not matter if you are native or non-native, what matters the most is the fact that you can help students achieved their language goals and desired band scores.
1
LMAO!! Hilarious! I upvoted it. lol

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today