Is there an advantage in being a native speaker for teaching a language?
By definition, a native speaker has a better grasp of idiom and dialect. They also have a "feel" for the language, that is, if it "sounds right" or "is a bit off". If they are well educated, this feel extends to good style. On the other hand, most tend to forget the rigorous rules of grammar even if they had studied it in school. To that extent, a native speaker is the best choice to learn the living language as it is really spoken and gain fluency.
A teacher is different. They study the target language rigorously for many more years than a normal person would. To that extent one expects them to know the formal grammar, vocabulary and style much better than others. This should also apply to those who teach a language that's not their mother tongue, provided they have otherwise reached the proficiency level normally attributed to native speakers. A regular teacher would be a good choice for those who wish to learn a language analytically rather than by some form of immersion.
Any thoughts on this?
Footnote: While I had to select a language under "this discussion is for learning" drop down, the proposition is not specific to English or any other language. I had to choose something because the submit button remains disabled otherwise.

