I think it all boils down to preference. They are more formal in their speech while Americans are rather lazy with words. And I do think that part of British accent charm is that we, in America, don't hear it that often. Just as if someone from Australia, Spain, or Germany would come to America, their accent would be interesting all the same. Even in the Southern States in America, they have a twang to their words that isn't heard in the Northern States.
My husband is from Ecuador and I am from Maryland. I think that him speaking Spanish is exquisite yet he begs to differ. He thinks that people from Spain have a remarkable accent. To him, and this is what he told me, Spain is to Spanish what Britain is like to English. They are both very proper while we are not.
-Rebecca