Search from various English teachers...
United States flagAliceCommunity Tutor
Telling a man or woman on Italki "You are Beautiful/Gorgeous etc." Do you think this is flirtatious or not?
I tend to get random private messages from men saying, 'You are Beautiful." "You are Gorgeous!" "You are sexy!" Typically that's all they'll say then wait for me to respond. Or they'll start asking me casual questions to 'get to know me' and when I say I'm not looking for friendship they act very offended.

This may seem like innocent compliments to some but it can come across as a bit too much for women. What are the men hoping that we'll respond with? "Thank you"? Are they hoping that we give extreme compliments back? Usually compliments to that extreme about someones looks is a way to 'flirt' 'pick someone up' 'playfully get their self esteem up.' 'make them feel bashful.'

Women: Is it common for men in your country to tell you these very forward compliments?
Men: Is it common for men in your country to tell random females this very forward compliment?

Me I'm a bit more reserved and conservative. I've never private messaged any person on italki and gave them any kind of compliment like this. I can't imagine doing something like this. To me it comes across as kinda creepy. There's something 'uneasy' and 'unnerving' about telling a random person how sexy they look. It's unsettling.

I may at times have some students that wear a cool shirt and I'll say, "Neat shirt!" or maybe they just got a hair cut and I'll say, "It looks like you got your hair cut. Looks nice."

But 'Beautiful' 'Gorgeous' 'Sexy'.... anything overly mushy/romantic is really borderline/crossing into flirtatious mode.

Comments · 47

18
It’s not a “lost in translation” kind of thing. Telling a women she’s beautiful in the first message is, at best, just plain stupid. For one thing, it sub-communicates that the writer primarily (or only) values women for their physical appearance. For another, how is a woman supposed to respond? Let’s see, “Thank you so much for informing me. I’ve looked this way all my life, but I’ve never notice it before. I’m so glad a complete stranger with no ulterior motives is sharing this important information with me.” Or how about, “Actually, I look at myself in the mirror several times a day. I’m not gorgeous, so with no other information about this complete stranger, I’m just going to have to conclude that he is a complete idiot or a liar.” Now, that’s useful information.

14
It's true that some cultures may allow and also encourage men to compliment women over their physical appearance, while other cultures frown this behavior upon. However, in any imaginable culture, when a man approaches random women with expressions like “Hey beautiful/sexy/gorgeous”, this man is clearly showing off his power. 

Yes, that's power, NOT flirt. The goal here is not sex: this man's well aware he's gonna get nothing, but doesn't care. His goal is to make women feel insecure when they’re in a public place. This man saying “Hey sexy!”, what he really means is “I’m the strong one here, and have every right on you!”. No wonder he becomes violent when the other part resists: his attitude is violent from the very start.

And for those who advance “Maybe they don’t know what they’re doing” … As an Italian man, I can assure you all: We know perfectly well WHAT WE ARE DOING in these situations.

So, Alice, my piece of advice: ignore these people, or tell them to go to hell. Don’t lose a single minute with any of them, they are total worthless. There’s nothing to earn from: no friendship, no help, no relationship, not even romance if ever one wanted some of it, nothing! It’s a parade! A display of power! They’re a such a waste of bytes!
14
These are not innocent compliments. That’s for sure! Sending someone you don’t know or barely know a private message such as “you are beautiful, sexy” or etc. is clearly haressment! Especially on this platform. There are lots of ways to compliment somebody but this is not one of them. Come on people! Don’t try to legalize this nonsense by saying that it is a compliment. We(also you) all know that it isn’t!
12
They're creeps. Usually they're not interested in doing English lessons either but just message lots of women here in the hopes of free lessons.
11
It makes me feel uncomfortable though. It's okay if my husband says that I'm beautiful or even a guy friend I've known for awhile. But from random men... It just makes me feel a bit weirded out.

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today