Search from various English teachers...
[Deleted]
in your opinion, is stealing to feed a starving baby wrong? Do not consider asking for food!

Comments · 21

10
I'll state the obvious: it's never as simple as "right" versus "wrong." As you've presented it--if the choice is stealing versus letting a baby die, stealing is obviously "less wrong" than letting the baby die.

I'm not a lawyer and even a lawyer couldn't answer without details, and in the US this would be state law and different in each of the fifty states. However, I think "child neglect" is a crime, and "petty theft" is only a misdemeanor.

In the United States, I am pretty sure that there are options other than letting the baby starve, stealing, and asking for food. To take one extreme example from in the town I live in: if it's a newborn, it can be abandoned at the police station:

It is the policy of the [Town] Police Department to provide a safe and hospitable refuge for parents or guardians to abandon qualifying infants at the Police Station in conformity with [state's] "The Safe Haven Act" which went into effect on October 29, 2004.  The Safe Haven Act allows for parents and guardians to abandon newborn infants who are no more than seven days old at police stations, hospitals, and manned fire stations.  The law further provides that the parents or guardians will not be subject to criminal charges for abandoning the infant in conformity with the law. 
9
If I had no other option, I would probably take the risk!
7
It disturbs me how many upvotes some of the really anti capitalist comments are getting considering websites like this only exist because of capitalist concepts and fundamentals and the strict alternatives have lead to much more horrible outcomes than just a hungry baby.. No ones stealing from you, so why don't you take responsibility for your own life and stop letting emotions guide your reaction to everything?

Stealing is wrong and I find it hard to let the ends justify the means (in this case feeding a baby.) There needs to be a more wholistic look at why or how this person got their baby in a position of starving in the first place to really be able to come up with a moral answer. The baby is innocent and should be taken care of but I start to question whether letting someone who has them in a state of neglect and starvation keep them and continue to steal is in anyway just for anyone in the situation.

7

Ideally it's wrong to steal but desperate times call for desperate measures. I'm not justifying stealing but if you're a real parent then you would find various ways to provide for your child. I believe in the saying, If there's a will, there's a way. I think that parents who are passive or those who wouldn't find a way at all for their kids should not be called parents at all. I cannot fathom the idea of my future kids starving and that's why I would move heaven and earth just to make sure they're well-fed

Honestly, I'm quite biased because if I were a police officer, I would let a poor person steal but if I see a rich person stealing then I would shoot the person or put them in jail. I'm compassionate for the poor but I'm quite rigid/insensitive with wealthy people because usually they're greedy and unsatisfied with what they have so for me, they have no excuse for stealing or getting more

In my opinion, I think that food should be free worldwide so that the poor would not have to steal at all in the first place. Basic needs like food, electricity, housing, education and even wi-fi should be free because the internet is not a luxury anymore and luxuries such as traveling are the only things that people should pay for. It sounds so entitled but I just like the idea of nobody worrying about their basic needs 

7
imo its wrong whether it's feeding a starving baby or any other similar reason because if we let the order of our society fall for whatever reasons, society would collapse as a whole. people would just find reasons to steal and i believe a lot of people already have legitimate reasons to steal, they do not do so because of their own morality and laws in place. 

i also like the catch in your question that we can not ask for food but we can always work to earn and pay for food or idk everyone has phones these days so they can barter them for food =P


Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today