Search from various English teachers...
Morocco flagzakariya
The universe is getting large, where? It out the compass of my brain to imagine where the universe is getting large

Comments · 5

4

To borrow in idea from Edwin A. Abbott's 1884 fantasy, Flatland, imagine that you have two-dimensional creatures that live on the surface of a sphere. In fact, we are not too far from that ourselves. We live in a strange world that is finite, but unbounded. The surface of the earth is not infinite in size. It is 51 billion hectares. However, it is unbounded. If we keep going in any direction, we do not encounter any end to the earth. After about 40,000 kilometers we come back to where we started, without ever encountering any edge or barrier.

Now, suppose that the earth is like a balloon, and that it is being gradually inflated. The earth is getting larger. The surface of the area is increasing. And yet, there is no single place where this is happening. It is enlarging everywhere all at once. And everything is getting farther away from everything else all at once. You cannot say "where" it is getting larger. All of it is getting larger.

1
As far as I know, there is no space outside the expanding universe. There is nothing. The universe is the only space, and as it gets larger, more space appears.
1
@Dan

I understood Zakariya's question more like this: Where does the universe expand into? The balloon that is getting larger is surrounded by air and space. So, when the universe is expanding, there should be space outside of the universe that is even larger than the universe and that's mind-boggling. We're a small speck in a huge balloon that's growing bigger. What's outside of this ballon? If we're in the ballon, we imagine there's an edge that we could reach. We could touch the rubber of which the balloon is made of. If the balloon expands more than the rubber could hold, it would burst and we would find us outside of the balloon in a different space. If we're outside of the expanding balloon (like the surface of the earth) we're surrounded by a different space than the balloon. Yes, we could crawl over the ballon and never reach an end but we're outside of the balloon. What's inside of the balloon (helium?) and what's outside (air?) and there could be things inside and outside of the balloon. So, for laymen like me, the balloon analogy just doesn't work because a balloon does expand into an outer space. If the balloon were in a tiny box it couldn't expand indefinitely nor could it expand indefinitely in a room in a house. It would eventually hit the limits of its outer space. If it were in the outside it could theoretically expand as large as the universe but if the universe is expanding itself, it's a definite space. A balloon inside a balloon can't grow bigger as the outer balloon.

I think this is just too much to grapple with for laymen or just for humans in general. When I read this following article I can't really picture those ideas: https://io9.gizmodo.com/5799335/five-weird-theories-of-what-lies-outside-the-universe. Because I can't imagine infinity. Even if I'll never reach an end of the earth, I know that its surface is finite and that there's a space surrounding the earth.

0
Frankly it's very difficult to imagine the limits of the universe. 
0
( i'm sorry isn't in english but i can't explain in english )


a vrai dire l'expérience du ballon est une bonne analogie pour pouvoir expliquer que ce n'est pas les étoiles, galaxies qui s'éloigne les unes des autres mais l'ensemble qui est en expention. 
mais il ne fait pas généraliser cette expérience sous peine d'avoir des contradictions évidente. actuellement il existe des théories mathématiques qui recherche qu'elle forme pourrait avoir l'univers, avec des dimensions finis et d'autres Infini
pour mieux conceptualiser l'infini regardé le travail de Georg Cantor 😉

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today