Search from various English teachers...
China flagLLing
Logic Test- Which one? I am really dizzy. My answer is B. Could anyone help me?

On Saturday Melvin suggested that Jerome take the following week off from work and accompany him on a trip to the mountains. Jerome refused, claiming that he could not afford the cost of the trip added to the wages he would forfeit by taking off without notice. It is clear, however, that cost cannot be the real reason, for Jerome’s unwillingness to go with Melvin to the mountains, since he makes the same excuse every time. Melvin asks him to take an unscheduled vacation regardless of where Melvin propose to go.

The reasoning is most vulnerable to which one of the following criticisms.

A.      It attempts to forestall an attack on Melvin’s behavior by focusing attention on the behavior of Jerome.

B.      It fails to establish that Melvin could no more afford to take an unscheduled vacation trip to the mountains that could Jerome.

C.      It overlooks the possibility that Jerome, unlike Melvin, prefers vacations that have been planned far in advance. 

D.      It assumes that if Jerome’s professed reason is not his only reason, then it cannot be a real reason for Jerome at all.

E.       It does not examine the possibility that Jerome’s behavior is adequately explained by the reason he gives for it.



 




Comments · 3

1
Choices A-D are inadequate given the text. E fits the text.
1
Yeah I like E too.  To disprove it Melvin would have to see if Jerome could go somewhere during an officially sanctioned vacation period, where Jerome does not lose his wages.
1
For this one, E is the best answer again.  Any unscheduled vacation will cause the same problems.  The statement "it is clear that cost cannot be the real reason" is a strong claim, and it is not supported by the argument which is meant to support it: "since he makes the same excuse every time Melvin asks him to go on an unscheduled vacation, regardless of where Melvin proposes to go."  Well, yes.  If Jerome can't afford a trip to the mountains, then he definitely can't afford a trip to somewhere more expensive.  Melvin has not refuted Jerome's stated reason.

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today