I know grammatical difference, but I don't fully comprehend a sematic meaning.
I know grammatical difference, but I don't fully comprehend a sematic meaning.
Comments · 3
It's difficult to explain since in most cases they can be used interchangeably. As an American, we almost never use the word "shall" in conversation. We find the use of the word "shall" to be way too proper and not casual/conversational. Almost to where its bizarre if someone uses it!
However there are some uses for the word. A very over-simplified explanation is this: "Will" is typically a word we use to discuss future events when "Shall" is something you can use for both future and present events.
You can say "Shall we go to the beach?" and it will be a complete thought, implying your asking if you want to go right now
You wouldn't say "Will we go to the beach?" unless a date and time is going to be discussed, this is not a complete thought and will not imply you want to go right now. Instead you might say "Will we go to the beach tomorrow?", we wouldn't say "Will we go to the beach now?" since we typically say "will we.." in reference to the future.
If you don't want to use the word "Shall" (which most Americans don't") but you want to ask about "right now" you might instead say "Are we going to the beach now?" or "Do you want to go to the beach now?"
Other than this example of using "shall" and "we" the words are virtually the same. I think in some english speaking countries they use shall more than others. I think it's a cultural thing.
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
