Search from various English teachers...
Iran flagNarenj
Is it reasonable to beat students at school to punish them? I remember I was a playful student. I was hyperactive and I did practical jokes with my classmates and sometimes I was in trouble. I remember I was imprisoned at small dark room for some hours as punishment. Or other day my teacher slapped on my face. I feared then my chair was wet!! I never forgive her. Never.
And now I am a teacher. I work in girl’s school. And I have a lot of playful students. Most of the time I can handle and control them but sometimes I have to be more serious. Controlling girls isn’t so hard. But the last year I made a crazy decision and I accepted to go to boy’s school twice a week. I wanted to have a new challenge and experiences with little boys.  
The first sessions were normal but after some weeks I understood it isn’t an easy challenge. They often beat and fight with each other. That year I understood that war and fight are a part of human nature. Because when there was no problem they beat and fight for laughing too! It seems they couldn’t be calm. The boys were so playful and fearless. I remember the principle often beat some students while I couldn’t see. I wanted to cry instead of boys. And I confess I sometimes had to hit on their shoulders and necks but my hand and soul were more painful although the boys laughed!!! I talked with my colleagues and they said we had to beat some crazy students to control class. But I couldn’t do this at all and I left that school and I know I can’t work at boy’s school at all.
Todays Iran’s educational system forbidden the teachers to beat and punish students in any way. They suggest nonviolence ways to control disorder and playful students.
Do think is it necessary to beat some students? My colleagues say yes Sometimes it is the only way. But not injure. Just for fear him. What is your idea?
Have you ever punished at school? How?
Is it usual in your country to beat students by hitting?  
I am waiting for your comments. Your idea is important for me. Specially the last question.
And I need someone to correct my mistakes. Thanks in advance.

Comments · 16

3
Kate, it doesn't matter 21st or not.
It is NOT that if now it is 13th centry and you are born warrior it is "ok" to rape women, because "it is just sucha  cruel century". Never.

And it is not good to do today bad things that are considered "good" or "aceptable" by everyone around you. For your sense of ethics you have heart and you have God (whatever name you call it, there is an atheistic counterpart to that notion). You dont' need 'century' to help you or to fight with you.
2

I remember that I was a playful student. Since I was hyperactive and played practical jokes on my classmates,  I sometimes got into trouble. I remember that once, as a punishment, I was imprisoned for hours in a small, dark room. On another occasion, my teacher slapped my face. I fear, my chair was wet after that! I never forgave her. Never!

When I became a teacher at a girl's school, I had a lot of playful students. Most of the time I could control them, but sometimes I had to be more serious.Controlling girls wasn't so hard.

But last year, I made the crazy decision to go to a boy's school twice a week. I wanted to have a new challenge and new teaching experiences with little boys.

The first sessions were normal, but after some weeks I understood that it was not going to be an easy challenge. The boys fought often and beat each other.That year I realized that war was part of human nature. Even when there were no problems between the boys, they fought for fun. It seemed that they couldn't stay calm.The boys were so playful and fearless.

The principal often beat some of the students when I couldn't see. I wanted to cry instead of the boys.

I confess, I did occasionally hit the boys on their shoulders or necks but my hand and my soul were pained from doing it. They only laughed!

Talking with my colleagues, they said it was necessary to beat the unruly students to control the class. I certainly couldn't do that, so I left the school, knowing I could never work in a boy's school again.

Today, Iran's educational system forbids the physical punishment of students. They suggest nonviolent ways to control disorder.


Hope this helps


1
well if you beat kids you are teaching them that violence is a way to impose your views on others, does'nt sound like a good idea.
1
Everyone is against of this corporal punishment, then who am I to support this nonsense. I was punished several times(beaten by stick, kneel down etc.) but as the saying goes in my mother tongue: "even if you beat me several times, I will still be the dead same(approx. translation). Punishing small kids never make any difference rather it instills the fear inside them that often stops them speak with an open mind. There are ways you can deal with them and as a teacher, one should take it as a challenge:) Discovering and shaping those naughty and innocent minds is no doubt a tough challenge, but interesting as well!:)
1

Do as I did the first day I went to jail.  To establish my dominance, I challenged one of the biggest guys in our unit to a fist fight until both of us were bloody messes.


No, that didn't happen.  AT ALL.

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today