Search from various English teachers...
Japan flagShigeki
About Pre-modification and Post-modification

Hi there,


I'm studying english. So I want to discuss with english speakers about pre-modification and post-modification to noun.

Please look at blow examples.


1. a tall man

2. the man who is tall


Is there subtle difference of signification  between 1 and 2 ? Or do listeners feel subtle difference between 1 & 2 ?


Thanks

Shigeki Mikami

Comments · 13

5
Actually, what is more significant is that you switched "a" and "the" for no apparent reason. Keep working on the use of articles, because it's much more essential.
4

Just a quick tip: when you're giving examples it's much better to give some context, rather than a sentence fragment. Even better, instead of making up examples yourself try to find a pre-modified noun and post-modified noun in a real-life text, and then ask us to look at them (in context, of course).


At the party, I talked to a tall man.

At the party, I talked to a man who was tall. (this sentence looks a bit unnatural without any context)


The first sentence is neutral; there's no particular emphasis on the word "tall". In the second sentence, there's a greater emphasis on the word "tall" because English speakers tend to place important words at the ends of sentences. Here's a natural-sounding example:

At the party I talked to a man [who was] so tall [that] his head nearly touched the roof!


If you're unsure which structure to use, it's best to go for the more neutral ADJ + N.

Hope that helps!

4
"The tall man", or "the man who is tall" carry the same meaning, but a true native speaker would probably use the shorter first version.  Also "a tall man" and "a man who is tall" also carry the same meaning, but again we would opt for the simpler and shorter option when speaking.
3
Adjectives are normally placed before the noun they modify: A happy man.
Clauses (i.e., phrases with a conjugated verb) are always placed after the noun: A man who is happy.
If we can use an adjective instead of a clause, we usually do, since it is simpler. On the other hand, if the idea is too complicated to express with an adjective, we'll normally use a clause, as Alan showed in his examples. Here's another example: "The man who is happy to be alive after he survived the accident" is a sentence where we cannot use pre-modification. In less extreme cases (where the clause is short and simple), it may be possible in colloquial usage to replace the clause with a participle (placed in front of the noun): "a just-married couple" or "a newly married couple." On the other hand, "a couple that just go married" would be more formal, and safer for the ESL student.
2

Think about this example:

Simple idea: I met a happy man yesterday.

More complex idea: Yesterday, I met a man who was so happy that he also made me happy for the rest of the day.

You can also create ambiguity if you use "who" clauses unnecessarily 

e.g. I met a man who was happy yesterday.

Did you meet a happy man yesterday or 

did you meet a man who was happy yesterday but is not happy on other days?


Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today