Search from various English teachers...
[Deleted]
How would you answer the two questions below?

1) You wake up in the morning feeling unwell and go to the hospital. There, a specialist gives you 3 pills and instructs you to go home and take one pill each half hour.

How long will have passed by the time you consume the third pill?


2) You enter a dark room carrying only one match, but you can identify by touching the objects inside the room that there is only one oil lamp, some newspaper, and some kindling wood. 

Which would you light first? 

Comments · 10

4

1) The question is not well formed. How long since when? Since last night? Since you woke up? Since you got to the hospital? Since you got the pills? If you follow the instructions to a letter, you take the first pill the instant you get home, the second 30 mins later, and the final one 30mins after the second one. 60 mins have elapsed since you got home.

2) The match, assuming it is a "strike anywhere" match. Otherwise, nothing since you didn't bring or find the match book or something suitable to strike the match on.

3

Hi Nilton,

Yes, you do need to know since when if you expect 60 mins as your answer. Your question does not state a reference, so I can supply any time since the beginning of time and it will be correct if I give the justification. You'll note that my answer had to include 'since you got home'. I could also have supplied the following answer and been absolutely correct:

If we assume I woke up at 6am, got to the hospital at 7am, saw the specialist at 8am, and finally arrived home at 9am the following are all correct answers:

1) 4 hours since I woke up

2) 3 hours since I got to the hospital

3) 2 hours since I saw the specialist

4) 1 hour since I got home

I'm not trying to be belligerent, I'm just pointing out your question is missing a reference time if you want to get 60 mins as the only answer. Other than that, good riddle!

Cheers!

3

1. 1 hour plus the time it takes you to get home.

2. the match.

2

1. Nine hours thirty three and a half minutes. half an hour to get to the hospital, seven and a half hours waiting time, three and a half minutes consultation time, half an hour to return home, an hour to take the three pills.

2. I'd leave. There's no food, no beer, no potential language partner.

1

Ok Vince,

I got your point. You are focusing on "How long will have passed by the time you consume the third pill?" considering every possible moment, whereas I focused on the time you take the first pill and the time you take the third pill.

I'm giving you a thumbs up to your remarks.

Thank you very much.




Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today