Search from various English teachers...
Iran flagSepideh
Are teachers who have studied linguistics at university more successful at teaching languages?

When we hear about teachers who teach languages, the first thing that maybe come into our mind is her\his major at university...We mostly consider who has studied linguistics at university is more successful at teaching related language...And consider her\his experience as a plus in related area at university...But is it true in all cases?


Comments · 16

7

Sepideh, I just wanted to make sure we were talking about the same thing. By "linguistics," I mean not the study of a particular language (such as English, Japanese, Arabic, or whatever), but of human language in general. So, someone with a degree in linguistics would have studied syntax, semantics, sociolinguistics, language acquisition, etc. That means that linguists can be expected to have a good grasp of how human languages are set up (so to speak), but they can't necessarily speak any language that's non-native to them.

Is this what you meant by "linguistics"? 

4

I think we need to remember that technical competence in a subject DOES NOT equate to teaching competence. 

Subject matter mastery does not in any way guarantee that one has the ability to convey this knowledge in a way that benefits others. Teaching is a skill.

Therefore the answer to your question is maybe, maybe not.

3
This sounds very much like the question, "Does a trained car mechanic necessarily make a good driving instructor?" :)
3
Ah, so we weren't talking about the same thing! Linguists (in the sense that I meant) tend to have an excellent understanding of grammar. They don't just know the mechanics (in the sense that they've memorized tables of tense endings, etc.); they truly understand grammar at a deep level. 

Anyway, as for people who did or didn't major in the language that they teach: people who've received formal training for a particular thing will typically be better at that thing than people who haven't received such training. But of course that doesn't go for everyone. You could major in (say) biology, attend a short course for teaching your native language to non-native speakers (and in some cases, not even that), and with a little bit of practice, become better at language teaching than most people (native or non-native) who majored in the language that they teach and then went on to get an M.A. in language teaching. But how often does that sort of thing happen? Probably not too often. 
3
For grammar, definitely. For other things? I'm not sure. 

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today