Search from various English teachers...
Congo - Kinshasa flagfabrice
What would you do ?

A little question comes back in my mind; you have probably already heard or read it somewhere but let me ask you anyway : 

<A man who has just died  arrives in a room where there are two doors. One leads to heaven and the other to hell.In front of each door is a guard who can just say Yes or No. The man knows that one of the two guards always lies and the other always tells the truth; But he does not know which one lies nor which one speaks the truth. He is entitled to one question only. what should he ask one of two guardians to find the gate of Heaven ?>


Thank you for reacting and giving your point of view without forgetting to make some probable corrections of grammar, orthography or even syntax.

Comments · 4

2

"Is the liar guarding the door to Heaven?"

If the door is to heaven and the guard is truthful, the true answer is "no," so the guard will say "no."

If the door is to heaven and the guard is a liar, the true answer is "yes" so the guard will say "no."

If the door is to hell and the guard is truthful, the true answer is "yes," so the guard will say "yes."

If the door is to hell and the guard is a liar, the true answer is "no" so the guard will say "yes."

So, if the guard says "no" he is guarding the door to heaven, and if the guard says "yes" he is guarding the door to hell.

Your English is good. The question is intended to be a puzzle or a riddle, not a real request for information, so it is more natural to call it a "puzzle" than a "question." Instead of saying "A little question comes back in my mind" is it more natural to say "I am reminded of a puzzle." The guard's possible answers, "Yes" or "No," should be placed within quotation marks. The word "but" should not be capitalized, you only do that at the beginning of a sentence. Similarly, the word "What" in "What should he ask..." starts a sentence and should be capitalized. I think the punctuation mark after the word "truth" should be a comma rather than a semicolon (but I'm not sure!)

Finally, the words "guard" and "guardian" are not quite synonyms. It is hard to explain the difference, but you want "guard" throughout. Most commonly, a "guard" is a person, possibly in uniform, possibly armed, who physically stops unauthorized people from coming through an entrance or coming through a military perimeter. A "guardian" is a legally appointed official who is given the job of taking care of some task; for example, a will often names "guardians" who have the duty of taking care of the children if both parents die.


1

I think my answer is logically correct. You are either in front of the door to heaven or the door to hell, and the guard is either truthful or a liar, so there are only four possibilities: you are talking to a truthful guard before the door to heaven, a liar before the door to heaven, a truthful guard before the door to hell, or a liar before the door to hell. I've shown that if you are in front of the door to heaven, the guard will answer my question "no" regardless of whether they are a truth-teller or a liar, and if you are in front of the door to hell, the guard will answer my question "yes" regardless of whether they are a truth-teller or a liar.

0

what tough is this guy ... And i start to believe he's right ... Lol


Thanks for this precision Mr. D. Smith

0

Hi Dan S

Thank you for you remarks, you bring a plus to my English beginner ... Lol

But i am less convinced of your answer given that one doesn't know which of the two guardians is a liar and which tells the truth ... :)

Imagine that this is the situation in which one will find oneself when one dies ... lol


You can also correct my answer :)

 

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today