Search from various English teachers...
Japan flagkeiko
I think both answers are ok though. (Past continuous and past perfect)

Hello. I have been studying English by myself reading the English grammar book called "English Grammar in Use". I got really confused and would like to discuss the following.



Unit16 Put the verb into the most suitable form, past continuous (I was doing), past perfect(I had done) or past perfect continuous (I had been doing).

 

……………is correct answer

(Underlined part is actually blank, but I wrote the right answer just in case.)

What I want to discuss is ⇒16.3.10. We were extremely tired at the end of the journey. We had been travelling(we/travel) for more than 24 hours.

 

What I thought is)Why “We had traveled” isn’t correct?




I think that both we had been travelling and we had travelled are ok. Is it ok to ask your opinions? Thank you very much for reading.


Comments · 5

0

Thank you very much for all the support. You don't know how many times I would like to "Thank you so much." to you. I am more motivated to learn your language. Thank you very much.

from keiko

0
Although the "we had been traveling" is probably best, I agree with everyone else that no native speaker is going to even notice the difference, let alone care. So yes, I think both are correct. "Had been" is better for the simple reason that it refers to an event that took place before another event mentioned in the same sentence ("we were extremely tired"). "I had had a long flight which is why I was tired when we landed." But, the reality is, English is pretty lousy-goosy in this respect, so a lot of people would just say "I had a long flight which is why I was tired when we landed." 
0

Both are correct. If you said that in a conversation, a native English speaker wouldn't think anything of it.  The question asks for the "most suitable form", meaning that the other options aren't necessarily incorrect, just that one is better than the others. I wouldn't worry about this very much since it is a very small detail.

0

The key is that you were tired.  We use had been [verb]ing if we see the result of a recently-finished action, and that action covered a period of time.

"We had travelled" shifts the focus onto the number of hours in your journey. We use the simple form when we talk about numbers of completed actions (hours travelled, books read, people visited...). It's not connected to your feeling of tiredness.

0

I agree that both "We had traveled" and "We had been traveling" are possible. I think "We had been traveling" fits the context a bit better, though. The point of the sentence is that "we" had gone through a 24 hour process and that it was going on at every single point during these 24 hours. That means "We had been traveling" emphasizes that the travel had been a strenuous and difficult process. "We had traveled" is better when traveling is treated as a completed event rather than a process. I would use "We had traveled" in a sentence like: "We had already traveled to Moscow before we visited Saint Petersburg".

I hope this wasn't too confusing. In any case, the difference is subtle and it would hardly be an error to use "We had traveled" in this context.

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today