The economy is a mess and hiring people is loaded with so many risks.
At the end of the day, a person's character is what companies hire for. Technical skills being equal, it's the person who 'fits' who will be offered the job. Technical skills are more or less generally available but reliability, honesty, maturity, agreeableness, balanced optimism (soft skills) ... the degree to which someone can handle stressful situations is what can make or break a company.
I personally would rather be asked questions face to face than have someone scanning my data and making decisions without fact-checking in person -- wouldn't you? I think we have to accept the premise that the world of work has changed because of social media / Big Data and revise decision-making in light of new realities.
I think now that we all know too much about each other from social media -- plus we have a mainstream media that assaults the public with bad news and conflict and disasters and tensions among people 24 / 7 -- this onslaught of news kind of pollutes the zeitgeist (IMHO) and makes people kind of pull back and go into 'risk management' mode and perhaps be more cautious than is ideal.
Sorry you're having this trouble. The good thing is that you, also, are gathering information about them; how they treat employees, how much they value mutual respect (or not), how they gather information and how they act on it. We all have more choices' they ask what they need to ask to choose you (or not) and vice versa. If you ever want to have a conversation about small-scale co-operatives, and local economic resilience, and other topics related to leveraging 'change' so it does more good for more people ... drop me a line. Good luck with this interview, Elena.