Search from various English teachers...
Russia flagElena
Hi Italki community. I would like you to answer the question that really worries me.

I want to bring up the discussion about job inrerviews (the situation when you apply for a job as a specialist in some area) : what private questions (questions that are beyand your professional area) are allowed to ask you on job interview ??


In my city in many companies it is a norm to ask me personal questions . They are :

- what my parents do ? (what kind of job)

- what my husband does ?

-  i live in my own flat or i rent it ?

- whether i am going to have children ?

Sometimes there are more questions about my private life than professional questions. I strongly believe the employer does not have the right to ask me such unprofessional questions ( moreover in situation when it is our first interview).

Is there the same situation in you country ?

Your answers are really appreciated .



Comments · 20

5

Ask any of those questions in the UK and the person would run the risk of getting sued. The latter three especially.

Another thing I have noticed is that in some countries, it is expected that the person sends a photo of themselves with their CV. That doesn't happen in the UK because it means someone could potentially be discriminated against by virtue of 1) race and 2) age prior to even getting to interview. The Equalities Act means it is illegal to discriminate based on: Age, race, sex, gender reassignment, sexuality, disability, religious beliefs, marital status, pregnancy and maternity concerns.

4

"because they take some risks "(Leon)
"And it is a job of security department to check my  biography." (Elena)

Elena, honestly I don't like the solution proposed:)  The world where all the employers know everything about everybody... I find direct questions much better than this.

Also you may just refuse to answer. May be in your city this won't work... But wait, you live in Moscow, just like me.
Here you have a broad choice of career paths, companies etc. You are more or less flexible in your choice.
And it is not that it is too hard to get a job here IF you are 1) Russian 2) live here 3) are educated/qualified.

So what I find reasonable is to maximize likelyhood of finding a good job, where 'good' includes pleasant working environment and boss who respects you. I do not think that convincing your boss in that he needs you is necessary right thing to do:) Possibly you will benefit from that he/she doesn't like you:)))
Then you won't find yourself working on this company for next two years... and instead find another job. Possible a better job.

3

No, here in the U.S. most of your example questions are not permitted.  Here is an article about our guidelines.  Many of the questions in your example would open a U.S. employer up to the potential of being sued in court.

https://www.thebalance.com/job-interview-questions-that-are-illegal-1918488

3
Those Questions are very personal and would not be asked in Australa. It's more about your experience  and if you are suited for the position advertised.
2

The economy is a mess and hiring people is loaded with so many risks. 

At the end of the day, a person's character is what companies hire for.  Technical skills being equal, it's the person who 'fits' who will be offered the job.  Technical skills are more or less generally available but reliability, honesty, maturity, agreeableness, balanced optimism (soft skills) ... the degree to which someone can handle stressful situations is what can make or break a company.

I personally would rather be asked questions face to face than have someone scanning my data and making decisions without fact-checking in person -- wouldn't you?  I think we have to accept the premise that the world of work has changed because of social media / Big Data and revise decision-making in light of new realities.

I think now that we all know too much about each other from social media -- plus we have a mainstream media that assaults the public with bad news and conflict and disasters and tensions among people 24 / 7 -- this onslaught of news kind of pollutes the zeitgeist (IMHO) and makes people kind of pull back and go into 'risk management' mode and perhaps be more cautious than is ideal.   

Sorry you're having this trouble.  The good thing is that you, also, are gathering information about them; how they treat employees, how much they value mutual respect (or not), how they gather information and how they act on it.  We all have more choices' they ask what they need to ask to choose you (or not) and vice versa.  If you ever want to have a conversation about small-scale co-operatives, and local economic resilience, and other topics related to leveraging 'change' so it does more good for more people ... drop me a line.  Good luck with this interview, Elena. 

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today