Search from various English teachers...
United Kingdom flagLucy Williams
How do I explain the difference between 'fell in love' and 'have fallen in love'

Hi, 

I am chatting with a native Italian and they would like to know the difference between 'fell in love' and 'have fallen in love'.

I am struggling to come up with a good way to explain the difference other than:

You can't use have fallen if the love has ended but fell can be used whether it is still happening on whether it ended e.g. When I was 18 I fell in love with Sarah. You could still be in love with Sarah, or it may have ended.

Any useful ways to explain this would be great.

Thanks


Comments · 10

2

"I fell in love..." at a certain point in the past [stated or not]

"I have fallen in love...." = I fell in love at a certain point in the past and I am still in love now.  

The present perfect meaning is almost the same as "I am in love with".  The present perfect sentence uses the expression "fall in love" in a slightly different way to the past simple version; the meaning is less literal and so it is not a typical example you can use to compare the usage of the two tenses.

Tough question!

2

Your explanation is pretty good.

I would add that "Have fallen in love" has some immediacy to it... you wouldn't say "I have fallen in love 18 years ago", you would use "fell in love", as you described. If the act of falling in love happened not too long ago, "have fallen in love" seems to work better...eg, "This morning, I met this girl/guy on my way to work and there were sparks... I think I have fallen in love".

(I think I've said "fall in love" too many times, it's lost all meaning to me :P )

2
I think you can use 'I have eaten lunch' and 'I ate lunch' for example. the difference is that if you have eaten lunch you are full and not hungry anymore and if you ate lunch then it is a finished task and maybe no result is felt. 
1

1 " I 've fallen in love "" : the action is still on ( it started in the past ans still goes on ) ; you're still loving the person

2 " I fell in love " : it happened in the past ( maybe in 2013 ) , you got a crush on the person on that date ,

and NOW...

2 possibilities may be that : 

you're still loving the person

OR

it 's finished between you and him / her

1

yeh it's a really tough question because the phrase that this person used was:

I went to Luxembourg and I fallen in love with this place.

I corrected it to say: you can say either:

I went to Luxembourg and I HAVE fallen in love with this place or

I went to Luxembourg and I FELL in love with this place.

Both are suitable in this case, which makes it difficult to explain the difference in other situations.

Thanks all for your help. I have sent the person the link to this discussion so hopefully it will help.

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today