Search from various English teachers...
United Kingdom flagFira
Benefits of a whatsapp group? Beneficios de un grupo de whatsapp?

Hi Guys

Don't mean to sound like a grandpa. But, could someone be so kind as to explain the benefit of a WhatsApp language group? I have not joined one yet, however, from pure observation and utilisation of logic the following seems apparent:

- No-one actually talks as communication is mostly through messaging (I though talking as much as possible was the foundation of language learning, doesn't messaging defeat the purpose? I thought this website was found for talking and practicing:))

-  There is usually one Native speaker of a language for every 5-15 of those trying to learn it. That poor one person has to answer a lot of questions. That poor one person also often seems to be a community tutor, meaning they are there to encourage you to book lessons with them (noting wrong with that)

- People sign up from all over the world, which is great BUT due to time difference between countries your phone goes off in the middle of the night because someone from the other side of the planet wants to know the difference between "you're vs your"

- if you have more then 5 people (and you often do) you phone generally goes off every few minutes, which could be destructing for those of us working or studying  

Google translation in Spanish

No significa sonar como un abuelo. Pero, ¿alguien podría ser tan amable de explicar el beneficio de un grupo de idiomas de WhatsApp? No me he unido todavía, sin embargo, a partir de la observación pura y la utilización de la lógica lo siguiente parece aparente:

- Nadie habla en realidad como la comunicación es sobre todo a través de la mensajería (yo, hablando lo más posible fue la base del aprendizaje de idiomas, no mensajería derrotar el propósito? Pensé que este sitio web se encontró para hablar y practicar :))

- Por lo general hay un hablante nativo de un idioma para cada 5-15 de los que tratan de aprender. Esa pobre persona tiene que responder a muchas preguntas. Ese pobre una persona también a menudo parece ser un tutor de la comunidad, lo que significa que están allí para animarle a reservar lecciones con ellos (notar mal con eso)

- Las personas se inscriben en todo el mundo, lo que es genial, pero debido a la diferencia de tiempo entre los países de su teléfono se apaga en medio de la noche, porque alguien desde el otro lado del planeta quiere saber la diferencia entre "you're vs tu" - si tienes más de 5 personas (y lo haces a menudo) tu teléfono generalmente se apaga cada pocos minutos, lo que podría ser destructivo para aquellos de nosotros trabajando o estudiando


Am I missing something profound here? Will joining a group take my Spanish to another Level:)?

 

Regards

Firuz 

 

Comments · 4

2

WhatsApp groups will go absolutely nothing to improve your level. The quality of writing in such a medium is going to be sub-standard (at best, even for native speakers), and the signal-to-noise (native-quality, insightful, or interesting messages, compared to the error-plagued, inane, beginner typos) is going to be minimal.

In fact, given that the 90% of the group will be learners, you will be exposing yourself to reading huge amounts of incorrect language, so I'd go as far as saying that joining such a group, unless your level is 0, will be detrimental to your learning, and you'll pick up more errors than learn new things. You're better off using your time reading newspapers, or blogs, in your desired language. And of course, much better off talking (or chatting, even though Whatsapp!) with someone.



1

Well, I think whatsapp group can be useful with clear rules. For example:

- Speak or write only in the target language, and do it in the own only for correcting the other's mistakes.

- Send voice messages in the own language to improve the partner's listening. Sometimes, with transcription.

- Send voice messages reading news or articles from internet, adding the link to the text.

- Avoid nonsense messages, constant jokes or threads of emoticons.

- Small groups (<10 participants)

- Only two languages, and balanced number of speakers of each one.

Otherwise, the groups become "una jaula de grillos" (a cricket cage) and there is no learning at all, only small talk and trivial chatter.




1
A voice of reason at last. Thanks Diego:)
1

I know that you believe Whatsapp groups distract from your studying and sleep, however, there is an option to "Mute" a group, so you can decide when or when not you'd like to receive notifications for the group, and then your sleeping and study sessions aren't disturbed.

:)

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today