I am always confused when I say something, like"I told him that I wanted to do it tomorrow" because I do not know whether I should say wanted or want or both. And another example is that"I received a phone call that I have to attend the meeting tomorrow", in this sentence should I say have to or had to?
Comments · 4
In your examples which use "tomorrow" (if "tomorrow" has in fact not yet passed and there is still no need to change "tomorrow" to "the next day"), I prefer the "natural sequence of tenses":
"I told him that I want to do it tomorrow."
"I received a phone call that I have to attend the meeting tomorrow" (As it is possible to use "wanted" above, it is also possible to use "had to attend the meeting tomorrow"; but as "tomorrow" has not yet passed and you have not changed it to "the next day", the reason for changing the modal expression to "had" in your example is NOT really because the "attend" "has already happened".)
Both your questions involve examples of Subordinate/Dependent Clauses (beginning with "that"). The first sentence with "wanted" is an example of Reported/Indirect Speech, which is a subset of Subordinate/Dependent Clauses.
In these cases you can see some "prescriptive" (as opposed to "permissive) rules here generally for the tense of Dependent Clauses [ http://grammar.ccc.commnet.edu/grammar/sequence.htm ]. However, sometimes it may not be so clear as to what category or rule should be applied, which is when a more "permissive" application of the rules may be necessary, as you will see described under "natural sequence of tenses" and the various "Batman" examples there in the Wikipedia article on "sequence of tenses" [ http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sequence_of_tenses ].
Similar rules can be found for Reported Speech: "prescriptive" rules at [ http://www.studyandexam.com/indirect-speech-for-tense.html ] and also [ http://www.grammaring.com/tense-changes-in-indirect-speech ], and a little more "permissive" at the British Council [ https://learnenglish.britishcouncil.org/en/grammar-reference/reported-speech-1 ].
The result is that is possible for either of your options for the two sentences to be used - even though some people might argue about the correctness.
Both of your sentenses are correct In the second sentance thehe reason you use "have" is because you are speeking in pre-tense. (something that is going to happen). You would use the word "Had" if it is past-tense or something that has already happened.
In the first sentance either one would work. Want or wanted is OK here.
I hope this helps.
I told him I wanted to do it tomorrow
I told him I want to do it tomorrow.
Both a completely fine!
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
