I came across the following article on The Guardian website. It's about a mother trying to teach French to her 5 year old son. She is not French but speaks it relatively well. I work with bilingual children so know that they are excellent at picking up a new language. What do you think of this woman's plan? Do you have any experience with bilingual children?
http://www.theguardian.com/education/2013/oct/02/teaching-my-son-french-bilingual?commentpage=1
Comments · 19
My daughter first learnt the mother tongue Urdu. We did not speak with her German. She only learnt some words and numbers in German. Then she joined Kindergarten and she learnt German very fast, becaue all the children used to communicate with each other in German. When she returned home, she used to say some words she learnt in the Kindergarten. She picked up the language very fast. Now at the age of 12 she speaks perfect German. But interestingly, she does not speak Urdu with me, only German and speaks Urdu with her grand parents. If I speak Urdu with her, she replies in German :)
I think children can learn many languages at the same time. Learning a foreign language learning becomes difficult for adults because they have already learnt a language and they try to translate from one language to another or try to find reasoning for grammar rules.
I think that theaching different languages to children is something that everybody should do. Every language is a richness that must be transmitted to the youngest generations so that they could achieve a better communication with people from different origins and cultural backgrounds. However, parents are the only people able to decide the way they want to bring up their children.
I myself am natively trilingual (I learned Basque at the school and my parents thaught me Spanish and Catalan when I was a child) and that has allowed me start learning other languages more easily. In fact, I am quite fluent in English and aim to learn Chinese, French and Italian.
It is quite common to learn more than one language at a time in countries with more than one nation -- Russia is the best example. I live near Bashkiria and there are Bashkirs speaking Bashkir and Russian equally good.
Speaking about the article (i've read it quickly, so i could have missed some key points of it), such idea has two sides, the first one is a child is able to learn quickly so he can speak the language as a native, but the second side is if you teach a language that is not your native language, you can give a child your mistakes, which would be hard for him to get rid of in future.
@alexandra, irrational are the expectations of the parents, sometimes.
I learned 3 foreign languages as a child. German and English from TV, French on holidays. But my parents had nothing to do with it. Although it did came handy for them on holidays, since I spoke better French than they did. I could translate for them. Funny experience for a ten year old. So sure a child can pick up more than one language.
But, irrational sometimes are the expectations coming from the parents. And it's not something only limited to learning languages by the way.
Maybe you did not understand me correctly. My daughter is 23 now, and still has problems with gender in Dutch. I said she came to the Netherlands when she was seven. No, I did not read the article, but I am always very vigilant when people tell me about these situations. Also that some children are fluent in a few languages does not guarantee the success of your child. Some children are just more intelligent than others. And parents always overestimate the ability of their own children, since having a brilliant child honours themselves. So, no, I am not enthusiastic.
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
