Search from various English teachers...
Iran flagFred
Who is a better language teacher?
Who do you choose as your language teacher if you wanna learn a foreign language?
I would like you to show your preference for one of the two below:
a) a native speaker without professional training about methods of language teaching
b) a non-native speaker with proper professional training about teaching methodology

Comments · 6

2
It would absolutely depend on my goals.
If I'm learning a language for fun, just to communicate with native speakers, then I would opt for having a lesson with a non-qualified native speaker, mostly because it's cheaper, but still good enough.
If I study a language because I would like to move to a new country, where I have to solve my official things in the country's national language, then I would choose to book lessons with a qualified teacher, because they likely have some experience with teaching people, and they also had to learn those things they teach. While a native speaker might not be able to explain why something is said in a particular way, a qualified teacher likely is capable of doing it.

I also think that it depends on your skills in the language. If you're a total beginner, I think an unqualified native speaker can help just as much as a teacher. If you're more advanced, a teacher can generally teach you more, in my opinion.
2
Being that I am already at an intermediate/advanced level in Spanish, I would choose a) because I mainly need to practice conversing in Spanish with natives.
0
Thanks for your comments. I like you point of view. But there are some points to raise in response. Firstly, most of native speakers, even if unqualified, charge more by virtue of being a native speaker which is an advantage to many language learners. On the other hand, as you said unqualified native speaker teachers cannot teach language systematically, especially for beginners, there would be lots of misunderstanding and problems. Such teachers have a very vague idea of levels and can hardly implement step by step progression...
0
So you think at elementary levels professional training is more important, no matter if you are native or non-native. But at higher levels native speakers can do the job more effectively.
0
Language is a tool for communication so it should be practiced through communication itself.
So I prefer the first choice as he know all the aspects of that language
It only my point of view...

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today