Search from various English teachers...
Kazakhstan flagZhan
Tag question
Hello there!

Could anyone help me with a sentence:
"I've decided to join a monastery."
"Oh you have, ________?"

I chose "oh you have, HAVEN'T you?"

But it says it's not correct and the answer must be
"Oh you have, HAVE YOU?"

I just wonder why?)

Thank you

Comments · 4

1
I agree with Dan I don't think it is a Grammar point, although it might be, you will have to wait to see if experienced teachers/tutors join the discussion. It is a common collocation that is used.

"haven't you?" form is used for surprise disbelieve.
" you have, have you?" would depend on the tone and why it is said. Maybe just asking or expressing surprise disbelieve.

'I'm thinking about adopting a baby" [THE person is 56 years old].
"oh you are, are you?"
"I have adopted a six month old baby"
[the person is young enough to care for a baby until it is old enough to leave home ]
"oh have you?"
"I have adopted a six month old baby[the person is 56 years old]
"oh you have, have you"
"My father is leaving home"
"oh he is, is he?"
"My father has left home"
"oh he hasn't yet, has he?"

"oh you have" is most often used when the person has actually done it and you are expressing surprise or you are just asking again for confirmation.

"have you?" is most often used when it is not so surprising or where there is not a real need to wonder did you hear correctly.

The comma would not be heard in speech in the UK again I do not know why it is put there in writing.


1
"Oh you have, HAVE YOU?" You are just asking again,
"Oh you have not, HAVE YOU?" you are also just asking again but by using the negative structure.

"you haven't joined a monastery, have you?" = you are expressing surprise or disagreement/disbelieve

"you have joined a monastery, have you?" = you are asking have they joined a monastery.

All forms only have "have you?" in the TAG Part" never HAVEN'T YOU ?

Haven't you gone to school, yet?" = when you use "Haven't" it goes to the front and the Tag is anything it is asking have you gone, done ,completed (whatever you stipulate in the TAG part.)

"Haven't you done your homework, yet?"
"Haven't you been to London, This year?"
1
Start with this imaginary discussion.
A: "Have you decided to join a monastery?"
B: "Yes, I have decided to join a monastery."

In order to ask that question, A must have heard something that made him think B might join a monastery.

Now, suppose he has heard nothing about this before. B says

"I have decided to join a monastery."

A is surprised by this. A finds it hard to believe. A is not sure he heard B correctly. He could express that surprise by answering the statement with a question. It is as if he is double-checking to be sure:

B: "I have decided to join a monastery."
A: "Have you decided to join a monastery?" [I.e. I'm surprised, did I hear you correctly?]
B: "Yes, I have."

A could also answer this way:
B: "I have decided to join a monastery."
A: "Oh, you have?"
B: "Yes, I have."

Again, A is expressing surprise or disbelief.

The combination "Oh you have, have you?" is a collocation. For no logical or grammatical reason, it is a common pattern of words. The combination of the two phrases intensifies the sense of surprise and disbelief. It even suggests disapproval.

(In the US--not sure about the UK) it would be spoken using a standard speech pattern. The accent would be on the first "have" and the first comma would almost be left out: "Oh-you-have, have-you?"

The phrase "haven't you" only works in the case where person A heard that B was going to join a monastery, and B is now saying that he will not. For example:

B: "I have no idea what I'm going to do next year."
A: "Haven't you decided to join a monastery?"
B: "I thought so, but when I visited one and talked to the abbot, he convinced me that I really wouldn't like it."

And there simply isn't any stock phrase or collocation like "Oh you have, haven't you?" or "Oh, you haven't, haven't you?" or "Oh you haven't, have you?" These phrases don't even make sense.
0
Could you give more examples of this pattern, please?

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today