Search from various English teachers...
Brazil flagBrenda Morais
shall or will ?
Hello, everyone!
My question is when we must use "shall" instead "will".
Is it a preference or grammar request?

thank you.

Comments · 9

4
1. You should never use 'shall' instead of 'will'.
Why? Because they're different. You can't substitute one for the other any more than you should use 'speak' instead of 'speaks' or 'no' instead of 'not'. They are different modal verbs, with different grammatical functions, and we cannot use them interchangeably.

2. To answer your question - with a slight correction - "Is it a preference or a grammar requirement?".
It is not simply a preference. Unfortunately, there very few native speakers who actually know how to use 'shall' correctly: most English speakers will tell you that 'shall' is just an old-fashioned form of 'will', or that you can use 'shall' instead of 'will' to make your English sound formal or fancy. This is untrue. In fact, there are rules about how to use both 'will' and 'shall', and you cannot use substitute one for the other.

4. So, when should you use 'shall'? The simple fact is that you never need to use 'shall' in modern, everyday English. Language changes, and these days there is only one current use of 'shall' which is worth learning about. It's this:

We still use 'shall' for questions in the first person (we and I) where the function is offering or suggesting. For example:
The weather's nice. Shall we go to the beach?
What shall we do this afternoon?
That bag looks heavy. Shall I carry it for you?
In these situations, you are offering ideas about what you, or you and the other person, could possibly do. You will find this is grammar books, and you will hear people say this, especially in the UK. However, even this use of 'Shall ...?' is optional. If you prefer, you can use 'Should....?' in the above examples and the meaning would be the same. Many British English speakers use 'Should...?' for offers and suggestions, and almost all US English speakers do.

2
I think they are the same but native speakers use 'will' in the modern English and considered 'shall' as old style English. They don't use it that much.

If anyone can correct our info.? :)
2
Amazing!
Thank you very much!
It is important to me solve this question.
The idea to think in portuguese and translate some sentences to english, specially when modal verbs is the point.

Thank you so much and feel free to contact me.

Best Regards.
2

Hello Brenda,

Simply do NOT use "Shall" in speech or writing.  It is antiquated.  You will find in it legal documents and in religious text.

"Will" simply states future tense, as in "You will be going to school 3 times per week," or "You will need to take out the garbage on Wednesdays."

Yes, you can use the work "will" more as a command, such as in "You will do as I say."

More commonly, to express a command, you would lean to using the word, "must."

"You must go to work."

"You must do your homework."

"You must get a medical exam."

I hope that helps, Brenda.

Kindest regards,

Gerry

2

This website explains when we use shall and will.

It is strange that we say "I shall" and say "You will or he/she/it will".

In Canada we do not really make a distinction between the conjugations, so we would probably use shall or will with all the pronouns.

https://www.englishclub.com/grammar/verbs-modals_shall-will.htm


The use of "shall" has gone down about 75% since 1800:   

https://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=shall&year_start=1800&year_end=2000&corpus=15&smoothing=3&share=&direct_url=t1%3B%2Cshall%3B%2Cc0#t1%3B%2Cshall%3B%2Cc0


Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today