Search from various English teachers...
India flagJake
Small confusion with two subtle different approaches for future reference with "might be"

1- Little Patrick loves to debate. When he grow up he might be a lawyer
2- Little Patrick loves to debate. He might be a lawyer


Do both sentences means the same thing? 

Sentence-2 might means that the person is already a lawyer.


Comments · 6

1

First, this sentence has a small error: 

Little Patrick loves to debate. When he growS* up he might be a lawyer.


 Little Patrick loves to debate. He might be a lawyer.

This sentence is a little bit ambiguous, and the meaning depends on the situation.

If you meet someone who loves to debate, maybe you can tell your friend "he might be a lawyer."

If you are talking about a child, it is like saying "He might be a lawyer (someday/when he grows up.)" The last part is assumed but not written or said.


0
@Chris You have filled me in with some really informative stuff like using "might" with "action" verb generally  refers to future and "stative" verb refers to present except when specified explicitly (addressing future). Thank you
0
Huh. It might be a difference between British English and American English, but I definitely assume present tense with stative verbs, unless context makes it clear that future is intended.  I'd have to see the actual text to see if there is enough contest to extend the future sense across the other sentences.
0
@Chris actually sentences(5 sentences) like sentence-2 have been found in the exercise part of oxford english grammer. In the first sentence of the exercise "When he grows up" was mentioned explicitly but in the next five sentences this was not mentioned explicitly. So I think it was suppose to be assumed based on the situation. Isn't it?
0

Yes, to me sentence 2 means that he already is a lawyer.

If you use "might" with stative verbs like "like", "love", "be", "seem", "know", or "understand", it will DEFINITELY be present unless you specifically add a future time like "when he grows up". EX: "Bob has been looking at Jane all day.  I think he might love her."

If you use "might" with normal (AKA "dynamic") verbs, it can either be present or future, but future is more likely. PRESENT: "I am usually fairly intelligent, but I might say stupid things from time to time." FUTURE: "If you enter that contest, you might win."

If you want to use "might" with "be" and imply the future, use "become": "Little Patrick loves to debate. He might BECOME a lawyer." For other stative verbs, use "start to".  "Sally and Joe love each other now, but if they don't work on their communication skills, they might start to hate each other."

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today