Comments · 34
Ryas said:
"I prefer British why because it is easy to understand than American"
Which British accent do you claim that you find "easier to understand?
Are you perhaps talking about a generic RP accent?
Some foreigners seem to think that all Brits talk like the Queen or Harry Potter. We don't.
There is no such thing as one single British accent.
There are many, many different kinds of British accents, and a lot of them are so radically different from one another that they are not mutually intelligible.
Most foreigners do not appear to know this.
Foreigners seem to think that all British people talk with a Southern English Home Counties accent. That is not true.
This man is Scottish. Scotland is in Britain. Therefore, this is an example of a "British" accent. Do you understand him? Probably not.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=5lGvPAGhW7M
This girl is from Yorkshire. Yorkshire is in Britain. Therefore, this is also an example of a "British" accent. Do you understand her? Probably not.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=sB3ieNhEsDY
These people are from Newcastle. Newcastle is in Britain. Therefore, this is also an example of a "British" accent. Do you understand them? Probably not.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZY4TT3VtR8o
This man (at 1:00) is from Wales. Wales is in Britain. Therefore, this is also an example of a "British" accent. Do you understand him? Probably not.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=zfwE7Gc6OT8
This man is from Liverpool. Liverpool is in Britain. Therefore, this is also an example of a "British" accent. Do you understand him? Probably not.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=5eALDOPFZLg
Of course Irish accents are Irish. Why bring that up? Ireland has nothing to do with it.
The Republic of Ireland is a completely different country. It is not part of Britain.
We're not discussing Irish accents. The topic is British accents versus American accents.
There appears to be some confusion about what a "British" accent is. As I have explained, Scottish, English, and Welsh accents are all British accents. A Scottish accent is a British accent, just as a Welsh or English accent is a British accent. (I have not mentioned Northern Irish accents because there is political sensitivity about whether NI people wish to call themselves "British" or not, and I prefer not to go into that).
I hope this information helps improve your general knowledge about my country.
Edit: by the way, we (British people) often refer to Great Britain as just plain old "Britain", just as Americans often refer to the United States of America as plain old "America". Perhaps you did not know this. I hope this information is useful to you.
Casey, you appear to be confused. Scotland indeed has its own identity, culture, and parliament. However, that does not change the fact that Scottish people are British.
Therefore, as I have already explained, a Scottish accent is a British accent.
You said "IMO" but it's not a question of opinions. It's about facts.
You don't appear to know the facts about Scotland.
Scotland is in Britain. FACT.
Here is a video for you featuring 17 British accents:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=FyyT2jmVPAk
You will note that several Scottish accents are included among those 17 British accents -- because Scottish people are British.
Scotland recently held a referendum to vote on whether or not to become independent from the UK. The people voted to remain part of the UK. Therefore, Scottish people are still British.
Scottish people have British passports and are British citizens. Scotland is not an independent country. This remains a bone of contention for many Scottish patriots, and many Scottish people do not like to describe themselves as British. However, that doesn't change the fact that they are.
You may observe the charming misty landscape over to my left in my avatar. That is Scotland. I live here. I know what I'm talking about. I live in Scotland so I know the facts about my own country. Please desist from disputing basic FACTS about my own country.
Casey, Scotland is part of Great Britain. So are Wales and England.
Therefore:
A Scottish accent is a British accent
A Welsh accent is a British accent
and
An English accent is a British accent
(in much the same way that a Texas accent is an American accent, and a New York accent is an American accent, etc).
Ksenia, many British accents are not mutually intelligible at all. If you read the comments on some of the videos I linked to, you will see many comments from people saying "well I'm British and I don't understand a word of this!"
Whether or not the general public in Britain is familiar with a particular regional accent will usually depend on whether that particular accent has had much exposure on national television (as opposed to regional television). For example, if there is a popular TV presenter (or, say, a character in a popular soap opera) who has a particular regional accent, then the general public will become familiar with that accent and be able to understand it (even if it's very different to their own regional accent) because they are used to hearing it on TV.
It's also worth pointing out Britain has a lot of regional dialects as well as accent. Accent is one thing; dialect is another. Accent just means speaking standard English but with a particular pronunciation. Dialect means mixing standard English with different words that do not exist in standard English.
Casey says:
... The difference between Britain and Great Britain is the former is England and Wales while the latter includes Scotland.
This is total nonsense. You are entitled to your own opinion, but you are not entitled to your own facts.
Casey, you are making a complete and utter fool of yourself on this thread.
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
