Search from various English teachers...
Italy flagMario Valenti
Personal disappointments behind the critical discussion about Italian society? Somebody told me "When you criticize your society's behaviors, you're actually talking of your personal disappointments."

That's true, but it also makes no sense. I'm gonna expain here. Personal frustrations derive from something, nobody chooses to be disappointed or unhappy. Most of times, disappointments derive from failures, problems with relations and feelings of inadequacy, but these troubles can only come from other's behaviour towards you, so when you tell me "What you claim about your own society is false, you're just trying to blame it for your problems", that doesn't make sense. My society caused me my problems. Why should I be unhappy, if all the things that cause me those problems are actually false? The answer is: they're not. If all that things were false, I wouldn't be dissatisfied with my existence. Dont you think?

I was also talking about my personal problems just because that general mentality consequently caused many problems to me and many other people!

I wrote that text about Italian society to talk of all the problems a weird mentality can cause to people, including frustrations and complaint. Nobody feels excluded or derided without a concrete stimulus from others and their behaviors. In this case, the external stimulus is the nazi mentality some people have. You can't talk about personal disappointments without talking of their cause , same way you can't talk of your society without talking about the effects it has on you (and others).

I received lots of comments by hypocritical people who actually enjoy other's problems. They all wrote "This is not a real critical discussion, you're just venting your frustration here". But how could I write a critical text without doing that? These two concepts are connected! My personal problems come from all the things about my society that I criticized in the last discussion! I think you should connect your brain, sometimes. As I have already said, we can't criticize something without mentioning the effects it has on us, and we can't talk about these effects without blaming their cause.

Comments · 11

5
I believe that 'Mario' or whatever his name is, has written all of this silliness as a gag. And you guys took the bait. No self-respecting man would post the things he has in a public forum.
4

Now that you have told us about the Italian society and the problems you face, what could be the solution to it because if you only keep complaining about the annoyances you are facing, then you can hardly be cheerful. What should be the possible solution to get yourself out of what you don't like? 

It is impossible to change the mentality or attitude of people towards you en masse. So what option is left? Maybe you can move to some other place where no one will judge you!

So far, you have only mentioned about your problems, but it's time you thought about solutions instead of posting the dark side of a society. It will be much appreciated if you talk about solutions because every society has their sets of challenges and your society is not an exception.

 

2

I think the logic you display in both this essay and your prior ones are great examples of the way people think when they have an external locus of control. If you are not familiar with the concept, here is a little explanation.  https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Locus_of_control   

1

KP,  there is nothing wrong to mention some dark sides or challenges that are present in our societies(one can easily know even without hearing from people belonging to those places ) but people may not accept them( just like here on a public forum) and will tag those claims as a generalization. Though italki has only banned the political and religious entity, still they have no idea that peole may as well feel uncomfortable with these type of threads.  I think you might have remembered a thread posted by an Iranian lady who also tried to mention some challenges in their society, but did you read the comments by other members? Most of the comments were against of what she mentioned. She might be right or even experienced what she mentioned in her day-to-day life, but as those problems are not faced by other ladies, they condemned her saying that she was making a generalization.

So, if someone says, "The society I live is very bad........" He is basically portraying all the people living in that society as victims, that's why people are objecting to what he says. Now, in that case, what do you think should be done because you can't really convince other that there is really a problem in the society? Should he keep posting them or ...?

0
LoL. That's all. 

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today