Search from various English teachers...
South Korea flagHayann Lee
What does "It has neither case nor spontaneity." mean?

Hi.

I'm studying "The Summing Up" by Somerset Maugham.

This is a sentence comes out from chapter 9, while the author was talking about his 'style' from one of his early books.

 I really don't get what is this sentence means. : It has neither case nor spontaneity.


<quote>

But what I am concerned with is the prose, for it was as an exercise in style that I wrote it. It is wistful, allusive and elaborate. It has neither case nor spontaneity.  It smells of hot-­house plants and Sunday dinner like the air in the greenhouse that leads out of the dining-­room of a big house in Bayswater. There are a great many melodious adjectives. The vocabulary is sentimental. It does not remind one of an Italian brocade, with its rich pattern of gold, but of a curtain material designed by Burne-­Jones and reproduced by Morris.

http://www.fadedpage.com/books/20160539/html.php 

You can find the whole text above. 


Thanks in advance!


Comments · 3

2

I think this may be an Optical Character Recognition error, where the software mistook an 'e' for a 'c'.

The correct phrase is 'neither ease nor spontaneity'.

1

"Spontaneity" has its literal meaning.  The text is predictable and perhaps boring.

"Case" - I don't really know.  "Case" is a feature of inflected languages like Latin and Russian. He may mean that the language is grammatically rough and unpolished but this is a complete guess. It may mean something completely different - perhaps even an archaic usage of "case".

"smells of hot-­house plants and Sunday dinner" sounds like the text is heavy, dense, disjointed, and uncomfortable to read. 

I should probably read more of the text to guess better so sorry for not having time to do this.

0

Su.Ki. 


You are right. I looked it up from the other file....oh...thanks for pointing out. 


Michael 


Thanks for your comment. That will be helping greatly.

Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!

Start Learning Today