I have met many language learners here and in other places that think that the best way to become fluent is simply through speaking, even though their grammar is not particularly good.
By the way that I have worded my sentence, you all can probably understand that I don't agree with this line of thinking. However, I wanted you to weigh in.
What do you think? At what point does speaking practice become more valuable to learning than grammar practice?
Comments · 6
There are other famous or simply polyglots out there that didn't become internet celebrities. Benny Lewis became famous because he wanted that to happe and he created the marketing of " speak from day one, be fluent in three months ", even if he himself says that that is not exactly what meant! Then I wouldn't be afraid at all to disagree with what he does.
In my personal opinion, a lot of people are mistaken by what Benny Lewis tries to sell. If I'm not mistaken, he studied two foreign languages at the unviversity, that being said, he learnt French or Spanish or both (I'm not sure, something like that) in a very structured way, then he started learning other languages " through his philosophy " of speaking from day one and etc but he already has a background learning languages and he knows how to do it, he's got the money to travel to those countries and force himself into a hardcore immersion, not like we normal citizens that cannot likely afford to do what he does and also many newbies have no idea how it is to learn a language, they try to do the same thing as Benny and they fail. Not to mentin as well that Benny vomits out there promoting the " non-need of studying Grammar " or saying that in other words but he himself studies it and when he speaks his main fluent languages, he makes sure that he's doing things properly (especially with my language), so what he promotes is not necessarily what he does!
I don't see the point of trying to speak until you have acquired a basic level of grammar that enables you to put the right words in the right forms together in some sort of order. It doesn't have to be completely accurate, but it should be sufficient to make yourself clearly understood.
If you need to communicate really fast (e.g. you are lost and starved and need to contact your embassy), go ahead and skip grammar.
If you want to learn a language, you must learn the grammar. You'll probably keep making mistakes for ever, but people wil at least get what you're trying to say.
Unfortunately nowadays people want everything extremly easily:
Lose weight without diet, exercises, effort
Make money without work
And with languages that wouldn't be different as well, they want to achieve something without having to struggle a bit!
Learning a language "well" demands effort and time!
Being a teacher, I could give bunch of examples of people who come to me with zero knowledge but do things properly and get to achieve a great result and those who come with no intentions of making an effort that is always at the same comfort zone level!
So as to the question of the topic, I think that every skills of the language has to be worked on! Reading, writing, speaking and listening and grammar is extremely important in order to make you sound good, fluent and make sense!
Yeah, Benny Lewis keeps saying that. He's one of the top results if I google "polyglot", so who am I to disagree with him?
But it does feel like it gets more important later on, and less annoying for whoever you're talking to.
I guess it starts to be very useful once you can understand and be understood in the language in a basic way. I think it becomes almost indispensable at the point where you can have most conversations but want to become really fluent.
Don’t miss out on the opportunity to learn a language from the comfort of your own home. Browse our selection of experienced language tutors and enroll in your first lesson now!
Start Learning Today
